This December, my PhD supervisor Mirca Madianou visits the Philippines for vacation and fieldwork. She plans to spend the Christmas holidays with her baby Alex in a nice beach resort before setting off to do her interviews of migrants' left-behind families from January to February. (Of course, I've booked her to do a MediaTalk already. Hehe.)
So in our last meeting, I had the surreal experience of acting like a Wow Philippines travel agent and recommending beach resorts for her to check out. Her requirements were: 1) she wants to spend one week in a nice, secluded resort, and 2) she wants to spend the second week in a place where she can do more stuff and meet "locals" as opposed to foreign tourists.
It seemed easy enough, but then once she pulled out the map of the Philippines and started asking question after question, I felt nervous and uneasy, as if I could not really "speak for" my country. Some of my blunders:
1) It took me a tad too long to find Davao on the map when I was talking about Pearl Farm. (She's still wary of going to Mindanao though, especially because of the baby)
2) She was asking about what to see and do in Bohol and Mindoro, and I could only say that I had never been to either but I did know that the chocolate hills are in Bohol.
3) Anxious about the advisory that there's malaria in Palawan, which ruled out her top choice El Nido, Mirca asked for another recommendation for the nice, secluded resort. And then I remembered reading a travel article about Amanpulo. She proceeded to ask, "So where's that in the map?" And again, yikes, it took too long to spot Amanpulo, which apparently is in a group of islands near Puerto Princesa.
4) She started asking about Boracay. And I have to pretend that I had been there, but--GASP--I've actually never, ever been. Shock. I recommended that she stay in my friend's hotel, but remained vague yet specific at the same time about what she should expect in Boracay. "If El Nido is like Santorini, then Boracay is more like Mykonos," this faker said.
I dunno. With Mirca, I'm quite comfortable talking about media theory and even empirical studies that deal with India, UK, even Greece. But when it comes to Philippine issues and current events, I feel more tense and confused. I remember the time when she asked me whether I thought Manila can be deemed multicultural or even cosmopolitan. And of course I gave two sides of the story (based on academic literature, of course), but I never felt like I answered her question sufficiently.
Anyways, the enjoyable part of our last meeting was when I recounted to her my Greece experiences. Mirca had listed some must-sees and must-avoids for me, as did my other Greek friends. And of course I wanted to give her my own cursory anthropological reading of Greek people and their/her culture.
1) I told her that, just as she had recommended, I went to Gazi, the site of her fieldwork.
But I told her that the place was pretty lifeless when we got there after lunch. And then I recounted how I was so baffled that I checked my guidebook later, and I was surprised to find out that Gazi has been called "Gay-zi" by locals and is a place that should be visited at night. Mirca apologized afterwards for not spelling it out clearly to me that it's a clubbing place and not a sightseeing place. It's just cute that she was prolly hesitant to be upfront and tell me to go to the Greek gay village. But we did see some cuties anyway so no problem. See the "boyS-in-the-background stealth foTOWgraphy" (Paul-Plazo 2008):

3) And finally, I told her that I thought that I had gained more insight as to her motivations behind doing her own PhD project Mediating the Nation. In her PhD, she examined Greeks and Turkish speakers in Greece and how they talked about "us" and "them" in relation to news consumption. I narrated how I spoke to a few locals and gathered that some Greeks tend to be quite wary of migrants, particularly non-Greek Orthodox (i.e., Muslim) migrants. This is especially interesting given that one other Greek that I spoke to during my travel said that their country's economic boom in the 70s/80s was a result of Greeks in the diaspora sending remittances back to the homeland. You'd think then that they'd be more sympathetic to migrants. Mirca did agree somewhat that this resurgence of Greek pride and identity in very essentialist terms made her take notice and examine nationalism in relation to the media.
Anyways... are you comfortable representing others more than representing yourself, or the collectives that you belong to? Is there truth to the idea that Filipinos know more about other countries than their own? How do tourist spots represent and misrepresent a country? And where do you recommend Mirca to go to for her holiday? What tourist place or splace represents the Philippines favorably? Which place or splace practices the virtue of infinite hospitality (and get me brownie points)?








4 comments:
Mirca sounds like a great person!
Representing myself -- presuming identity as a performance, it would seem like there is a necessity to present oneself to anOther as someone apart from the person of everyday life of everyday life. It's not the whole self, just a stylized caricature of it. Then again, who has time for everything anyway?
Filipinos knowing more of other countries -- perhaps if they are associated with diaspora of that particular country, seeing through their eyes so to speak. They might not explicitly have facts and figures but certainly the culture they have grown in and helped shape must be like as intimate as the air they breathe -- they don't need to pay attention to it but it's distinctly there.
Tourist spots -- I think caricatures again, like how some people would think the Philippines is one big beach or jungle. I'm thinking regionalism is too subtle for foreigners/tourists to realize nuances in culture and places, apart from the different languages.
Bohol! They can tour Bohol for a whole day (tarsiers, underground cave, chocolate hills, lunch buffet at Loboc River, Baclayon Church and museum, bee farm, artificial rainforest). Then she can stay in Panglao island -- actually, Amorita beach resort (where HappySlip Christine stayed). Staff are so friendly and it's very peaceful. At night she can enjoy the nightlife (basically live acoustic music) walk around the beach a la Boracay, with a lot less crowds, enjoy dinner by the sea. And diving if it's convenient.
Amanpulo: never been there, but it's too outdated to be worth going to anymore, and kids aren't helpful to the ambience, which is the source of many complaints against it.
Club Noah Palawan: excellent service as well, I hear, plenty of activities.
Davao: Sam's from Davao, she could definitely help you out!
I got this idea from a commercial but maybe relatives of friends could help out during the second week? Practicing hospitality and all. Haha, I'm referring to a representation of a representation.
If there was a tourist spot representing the Philippines I'd choose Boracay. There's a beach (Orientalist caricature) and all kinds of people go there. Way too crowded for me though.
re:multicultural/cosmopolitan Manila: Tin and I are working on a study with manila being a microcosm of the philippines, taking off from my study on regional diaspora. so we'll see. :)
This was a really long comment! Dre
this is exciting news!
tourist spots represent the best and worst of a country, just like its citizens. from this POV, there can be no misrepresentation. but of course, we want a balance. fortunately, mirca will be coming in december, so the air will be festive wherever she goes :)
considering the cost of domestic travel, it's no wonder most filipinos do not really know the philippines. that said, i'm the wrong person to ask about this!
Dre! Gosh! You're excited to go back to school, aren't you? This is like a preliminary essay right here. You've got identity-as-performance, diaspora, regionalism, Orientalism, representation... the whole kaboodle! :) I'll so miss you in MAG.
I'm curious about the ad with the hospitality bit. You gotta tell me more about it.
And a study on Manila with Tin? Whoo! Can you be my RA na lang? :)
damn! i didn't expect your greece post to be so thought-provoking! i thought there would be more boys. haha!
knowing more about other countries than my own - interesting question. part of my travel itch seems to have come from the realization that i didn't know enough about other countries as i did about my own country. and the question followed: "why CAN'T i engage with the world as deeply as i am engaged with my own country?" has set me off on all these trips.
i remember my glee club touring days -- they were such an ambassadorial experience, haha! "forced" to talk to curious foreigners about the philippines on a daily basis, god help you if you had nothing to say! a lot of it was putting erroneous images to right -- no we don't eat with chopsticks, yes we have skyscrapers, no we don't live in treehouses, yes we speak english with american accents because we were colonized! and you realize that the little you do know about your country is already a lot!
for mirca's requirement #1, boracay might still be a good place provided she stays in one of the more secluded areas like diniwid beach. she can just walk/trike over to white beach for the chica restos and nightlife. what to expect in boracay: use gorgeous sunsets and the most perfect powdery white sand as a come-on! also agree with bohol as an option.
requirement #2 might be fulfilled by cebu. she can "do" more stuff there since it's a city, like shop (cebu apparently makes a lot of export-quality goods), sightsee, eat, take side trips to nearby islands like malapascua. i may be wrong, but cebu doesn't strike me as overly foreigner-infested.
sayang naman, ayaw ba talaga niya mag-palawan? :-(
Post a Comment